Several recent articles in the blogosphere have relit the controversial debates surrounding Calvinism vs Arminianism. And as we all know this discussion has been a centuries old one which has led to many different factions in the Protestant Church.
What gave rise this time, was Dr. Olson’s call late September for all of us to admit our Theologies are flawed. Which led to some animated discussions and Dr. Olson’s further explanations in several posts (1,2) as to what he, as an Arminian, perceives to be the challenge with Calvinist theology. But for all clarity, he also admitted the flaws he can see in the Arminian approach:
Let me step out and dare to name a problem with Arminian theology and then challenge a committed Calvinist to do the same. One thing I wrestle with about Arminianism is the mystery of free will. I don’t know how it works. There does seem to be an element of uncaused effect in it. (I don’t think that’s a contradiction, but it is a mystery.) And I’m not sure how God foreknows with absolute certainty libertarianly free decisions that haven’t been made yet. That does seem to be a mystery and therefore a problem insofar as I would very much like to have an answer for it but don’t. These elements of classical Arminianism cause me some cognitive dissonance
Note how he puts it forth as a dare. Michael Patton, of Reclaiming the Mind ministries and for whom I have a tremendous amount of respect, took Dr. Olson up on the dare and admitted that:
As a Calvinist, I find it very difficult to understand why God did not choose everyone. All explainations that are given in my camp are terrible. I am not saying that they are necessarily wrong (I don’t know), but they are completely unsatisfying. There is simply no problem with unconditional election of all people. The problem is when God, who loves all people, only elects some.
And just as Dr Olson continued to explain his further challenges with Calvinism, Michael explained his challenges with Arminianism.
So far, the background. And why does it matter ? Why do we care ?
Continue reading →